State v. Fernandez

Summarized by:

  • Court: Oregon Supreme Court
  • Area(s) of Law: Criminal Law
  • Date Filed: 04-30-2026
  • Case #: S071340
  • Judge(s)/Court Below: Flynn, C.J, for the Court.
  • Full Text Opinion

ORS 138.105(8)(c)(A) permits appellate review of errors in “ranking the crime seriousness classification of the current crime.” That provision provides for direct appeal as a path to review Article I, section 16 challenges.

Fernandez was sentenced to prison using a “grid system” for criminal sentencing. The Oregon Court of Appeals affirmed the lower court's ruling. On appeal to the Oregon Supreme Court, Fernandez argued that the lower courts violated his constitutional rights to a proportionate punishment. Or. Const., art. I, § 16. 

Under ORS 138.105(a), the Court of Appeals has no authority to review a trial court's sentencing if it was made according to state guidelines, but ORS 138.105(c)(A) provides an exception for cases which involve “ranking the crime seriousness classification of a current crime.” The Court ruled that the statutory language was unclear about whether “ranking” included cases where the proportionality of a sentencing guideline was being challenged. After considering the statute's historical context, the Court determined that the legislature intended to include “vertical proportionality” challenges within its exceptions. Finally, Fernandez's appeal was deemed a vertical proportionality challenge because he argued that his sentencing was more severe than “less serious” crimes in the grid system. 

“The decision of the Court of Appeals is reversed. The case is remanded to the Court of Appeals for further proceedings.” 

Advanced Search


Back to Top