Oregon Supreme Court

2025

January 1 summary

Huseky v. Department of Corrections

Under ORCP 21, a plaintiff need not plead an enforceable right to future employment to allege economic damages.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Civil Procedure

February 0 summaries

March 1 summary

Gilbert / March v. Dept. of Energy

Under OAR 345-0371(9), EFSC is required to grant contested case proceedings only when it raises a significant issue of fact or law that is reasonably likely to affect the amendment.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Administrative Law

April 2 summaries

State v. Cotter

Under State v. Meyrick and State v. Langley, a waiver of counsel must be knowing and intentional, with the preferred means being colloquy on the record, and courts may not presume waiver from a silent record.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Criminal Procedure

Twigg v. Admiral Ins. Co.

“Whether an insurance claim seeks recovery for an “accident” does not depend on a plaintiff’s pleading decisions in the underlying claim against the insured but depends instead on whether there is a basis in fact for imposing tort liability.” … Because the insured “breached a duty imposed by law, and not one solely arising from contract”, the property damage is covered under the insurer’s policy for indemnification.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Contract Law

May 2 summaries

State v. Perez

“[A] plain-error challenge based on the prosecution’s purportedly improper arguments to the jury [requires] that the defendant establish that it is obvious and beyond reasonable dispute that the prosecutor’s statements were improper, whether because they misstated the law, adversely commented on the defendant’s exercise of a constitutional right, referenced matters not in evidence, or otherwise could only be understood to have urged the jury to draw an impermissible inference.”

Area(s) of Law:
  • Criminal Law

KKMH Properties, LLC v. Shire

Under ORS 90.392(3)(c) must state that a violation can be cured when, as a matter of law, a tenant has a right to cure the violation.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Landlord Tenant

June 2 summaries

State v. Walsh

A provision in a plea agreement that the court “may impose” consecutive sentences is ambiguous and can mean that the court has the authority to impose consecutive sentences with or without certain statutory findings.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Post-Conviction Relief

State v. Burton

Absence of evidence may be argued to show reasonable doubt, but evidence that is not in the record with the potential to mislead the jury may not be.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Evidence

July 2 summaries

Delta Airlines, Inc. v. Department of Revenue

A legislative tax classification is constitutional if it is rationally related to a legitimate legislative purpose

Area(s) of Law:
  • Tax Law

State v. Logston

Where there is no other limiting authority, a court is permitted under the Oregon Constitution to impose consecutive sentences when the crimes involve different victims, even across separate cases and after a probation revocation.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Post-Conviction Relief

August 1 summary

East Valley Water v. Water Resources Commission

The Water Resources Commission must consider all seven factors under ORS 537.170(8) to determine whether the rebuttable presumption of public interest is overcome.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Water Rights

September 7 summaries

PacifiCorp v. Department of Revenue

The Tax Court is required to follow the Department of Revenue's rule and use the WSATA Handbook when calculating property value.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Tax Law

Dept. of Human Services v. M. G. J.

Under ORS 419B.656, juvenile courts do not need to hold a contested evidentiary hearing after a tribe submits an order or judgment for tribal customary adoption.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Tribal Law

Hathaway v. B & J Property Investments, Inc.

ORS.125 does not contain a discovery rule; the one-year limitation period begins when the agreement is breached.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Landlord Tenant

Hathaway v. B & J Property Investments, Inc.

ORS 12.125 does not contain a rule of discovery, so the Oregon Landlord Tenant Act's statute of limitations begins running "when a rental agreement is allegedly breached or when an alleged violation of ORS chapter 90 has occurred."

Area(s) of Law:
  • Landlord Tenant

In re Abel

“Under ORPC 8.4(a)(3), the Bar must prove ‘by clear and convincing evidence’ that a lawyer had actual knowledge of a false statement at the time the statement was made.”

Area(s) of Law:
  • Professional Responsibility

State v. Hernandez-Esteban

It is not within the permissible bounds of discretion for a trial court to do nothing when case specific substantial prejudice has been established

Area(s) of Law:
  • Criminal Procedure

Teitelman v. SAIF

ORS 656.325(1)(e) authorizes a WRME if the “claimant has requested ‘a hearing on a denial of compensability that is based on’ an IME report”...“a claimant’s right to a WRME is not limited to the grounds of denial at the time of the hearing request” because an insurer may rely on an IME after the claimant made the hearing request.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Workers Compensation

October 3 summaries

Jared v. Harmon

“[A] tenant’s obligation to comply with ORS 90.325 is not dependent upon a landlord’s compliance with the habitability requirements in ORS 90.320.” Jared v. Harmon, 374 Or 381, 398-99 (2025).

Area(s) of Law:
  • Landlord Tenant

Jared v. Harmon

A violation of habitability by a landlord does not permit a tenant to violate their own duties to keep the premises clean and sanitary

Area(s) of Law:
  • Landlord Tenant

State v. Wall

Under ORS Chapter 132, the decision "whether to receive testimony from a witness in person or remotely—belongs, at least in first instance, to the grand jury itself."

Area(s) of Law:
  • Criminal Procedure

November 2 summaries

State ex rel Torres-Lopez v. Fahrion

The type of time ORS 137.370(4) applies to is not limited to time physically spent in a county jail but includes all in which a person is in the legal custody of a jail for the crime.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Criminal Procedure

State v. Cortes

Weapons are "instruments designed primarily for offensive or defensive combat or instruments that would reasonably be recognized as having substantially the same character, and not . . . tools or objects designed primarily for utility, even when those tools can be used as weapons under some circumstances."

Area(s) of Law:
  • Criminal Law

December 2 summaries

Perkins v. Fhuere

Under ORS 138.530(1)(a), post-conviction relief is available when a substantial constitutional violation in the proceedings results in a conviction. Further, pursuant to the PCHA, a person asserting a claim of innocence based on false testimony must also raise the claim that prosecution "knowingly solicited the false testimony or allowed it to go uncorrected."

Area(s) of Law:
  • Post-Conviction Relief

Arellano-Sanchez v. Thrasher

ORS 144.350 does not authorize the re-arrest of former detainees solely on the grounds that DOC has reevaluated the applicable sentencing law and determined that release was improper.

Area(s) of Law:
  • Criminal Law

Back to Top