- Court: Oregon Supreme Court
- Area(s) of Law: Criminal Procedure
- Date Filed: 03-12-2026
- Case #: S071665
- Judge(s)/Court Below: Bushong, J. for the Court; DeHoog, J. concurring
- Full Text Opinion
Defendant sought review of two felony-murder convictions arising from an apartment
fire that killed his estranged girlfriend’s roommates. He assigned error to denial of his
suppression motion and demurrer. Defendant argued that detectives induced his admissions
through implied promises of leniency and that Oregon’s felony-murder statute unconstitutionally
presumed culpability for death or imposed strict liability. The State maintained that his
statements were voluntary and the statute constitutional.
Under ORS 136.425(1) and Article I, section 12, the State must prove voluntariness by a preponderance of the evidence. The controlling question is whether, considering all circumstances, “a defendant’s free will was overborne and his or her capacity for self-determination was critically impaired.” State v. Jackson, 364 Or 1, 21 (2018). Encouragement to tell the truth is distinguishable from inducement conveying “the idea of a threat or promise.” Id. at 24. Despite detectives’ pressure, Defendant showed no impairment, received breaks, and continued denying intentional ignition. The Court concluded that his admissions were voluntary. State v. Monaco, 375 Or 1, 15–16 (2026).
Due process prohibits conclusively presuming a required element or shifting the prosecution’s burden. Sandstrom v. Montana, 442 US 510, 524 (1979). However, under ORS 163.115(1)(b), “the only culpable mental state required” is established by proving the predicate felony’s mental state. Monaco, 375 Or at 18. Because separate culpability for causing death was not an element, the statute presumed no required element; the State still had to prove intentional arson beyond a reasonable doubt. Id. at 24–25. The Court also rejected the strict-liability challenge: statutory presumptions favoring mental-state requirements did not establish a constitutional mandate, and felony murder’s historical acceptance supported its validity here. Id. at 26–30. The decision of the Court of Appeals and the judgment of the circuit court are affirmed.


