- Court: Oregon Supreme Court
- Area(s) of Law: Water Rights
- Date Filed: 08-07-2025
- Case #: S070604
- Judge(s)/Court Below: DeHoog, J., for the Court; Bushong, J., dissenting.
- Full Text Opinion
In 2014, the Water Resources Commission denied the petitioner’s application for a new reservoir because the plan would go against public interests by inundating wildlife habitats. On appeal, petitioners argued that the lower court erred for two reasons: (1) the public interests test should only apply to the quantity of water, not general ecological benefits, and (2) the Commission failed to apply the proper balancing test for determining if the plan was in the public interests.
Under ORS 537.153(2), petitions receive a rebuttable presumption that they would not be detrimental to the public interest if they meet four factors. To overcome this rebuttable presumption, under ORS 537.170(8), the Commission must consider seven factors to determine whether an application “would impair or be detrimental to the public interest.”
The Court first found that “the public interest” does not only apply to the quantity of water but also includes general benefits included in a senior water right. However, the Court also ruled that the Commission must balance all seven factors under ORS 537.170(8) after the rebuttable presumption of public interest has been met under ORS 537.153(2). Because the Commission only expressly considered one of the seven factors, ORS 537.170(8)(f), the lower court erred by affirming the petition’s denial.
“The order of the Water Resources Commission is reversed, and the case is remanded to the Water Resources Commission for further proceedings.”


