State v. Velazquez-Munoz

Summarized by:

  • Court: Oregon Court of Appeals
  • Area(s) of Law: Criminal Procedure
  • Date Filed: 09-10-2026
  • Case #: A181577
  • Judge(s)/Court Below: Shorr, P.J.; Powers, J.; O’Connor, J.
  • Full Text Opinion

Under ORS 135.865, a discovery violation does not require a remedy absent prejudice. State v. Pilon, 321 Or App 460, 473, 516 P3d 1181 (2022). An erroneous denial of a for-cause juror challenge does not require reversal absent prejudice to a substantial right. State v. Villeda, 372 Or 108, 119, 546 P3d 268 (2024). Unpreserved prosecutorial misconduct constitutes plain error only when the challenged statements are obviously improper and incurable. State v. Perez, 373 Or 591, 606-07, 568 P3d 940 (2025).

Defendant appealed a DUII conviction, raising four assignments of error concerning a
discovery violation, a for-cause juror challenge, and statements made during the State’s rebuttal
closing argument. Defendant first assigned error to the denial of a continuance after the State
failed to provide witnesses’ addresses and telephone numbers as required by ORS 135.815.
Under ORS 135.865, whether a discovery violation requires a remedy turns on prejudice,
measured by “the extent of surprise and the impact of the violation on trial preparation.” State v.
Pilon, 321 Or App 460, 473, 516 P3d 1181 (2022). The Court held that Defendant was not
prejudiced because counsel knew the witnesses’ identities and employers, had adequate
information to contact them, and had declared herself trial-ready before raising the issue.
Defendant next assigned error to the denial of his for-cause challenge to a prospective juror who
misunderstood the burden of proof. Defendant argued that the trial court’s refusal to strike the
juror “implicitly endorsed” her misunderstanding and improperly influenced the seated jury. The
Court held that Defendant failed to demonstrate prejudice to a substantial right because the
challenged juror was not seated, the court and parties repeatedly stated the correct burden of
proof, and the record did not indicate that the seated jury misunderstood that burden. State v.
Villeda, 372 Or 108, 119, 546 P3d 268 (2024).
Finally, Defendant argued that two statements in the State’s rebuttal constituted plain
error. Prosecutorial statements constitute plain error only when they are obviously improper and
incurable. State v. Perez, 373 Or 591, 606-07, 568 P3d 940 (2025). Characterizing Defendant’s
theory as a “story” was susceptible to a permissible interpretation and thus not obviously
improper. Although the Court noted that even by assuming that accusing defense counsel of
using “inflammatory things” to “scare” the jury was improper, the isolated statement was curable
by an instruction and therefore did not constitute plain error. Affirmed.

Advanced Search


Back to Top