Xcaliber Int’l Ltd., L.L.C. v. State

Summarized by:

  • Court: Oregon Court of Appeals
  • Area(s) of Law: Administrative Law
  • Date Filed: 08-26-2026
  • Case #: A184673
  • Judge(s)/Court Below: Joyce, J. for the Court; Ortega, P.J., & Hellman, J.
  • Full Text Opinion

A bill is considered “one for raising revenue” when it “collects or brings money into the treasury ... [and] possesses the essential features of a bill levying a tax.” Bobo v. Kulongoski, 338 OR 111, 122, 107 P.3d 18 (2005) (citation omitted).

The State of Oregon appealed the trial court’s decision to grant respondent’s motion for summary judgment and deny the State’s. The State assigned error to the trial court’s finding that House Bill (HB) 2128 violated the Oregon Constitution’s Supermajority Clause because the bill was “one for raising revenue” that should have required a three-fifths vote to pass.

A bill is considered “one for raising revenue” when it “collects or brings money into the treasury ... [and] possesses the essential features of a bill levying a tax.” Bobo v. Kulongoski, 338 OR 111, 122, 107 P.3d 18 (2005) (citing Northern Counties Trust v. Sears, 30 Ore. 388, 402, 41 P 931 (1895)).

Applying the two-part test from Bobo, the Court determined that HB2128 met the first element of the test but did not meet the second element because the revenue generation that occurred was only incidental to the bill’s main purpose of protecting public health. Accordingly, the Court determined that the bill did not violate the Supermajority Clause, and the trial court’s rulings on summary judgment were in error.

“Reversed and remanded.”

Advanced Search


Back to Top