- Court: Oregon Court of Appeals
- Area(s) of Law: Criminal Procedure
- Date Filed: 06-18-2025
- Case #: A180342
- Judge(s)/Court Below: Ortega, P.J.; Hellman, J.; O'Connor, J., vice Mooney, S.J.;
- Full Text Opinion
Defendant appealed a judgment revoking his probation based on incriminating text messages discovered by probation officers on his phone. The trial court overruled Defendant’s Miranda objection, concluding that suppression was unavailable in a probation revocation proceeding. Defendant assigned error to that ruling, arguing that the messages resulted from a Miranda violation and should have been excluded. The State disputed preservation, but the Court concluded that Defendant sufficiently raised the issue. Turning to the merits, the Court held that “[t]he exclusionary rule barring the admission of evidence obtained in violation of Article I, section 12, of the Oregon Constitution, applies in probation violation hearings, including probation revocation proceedings.” State v. Moran, 341 Or App 309, 310 (2025). The Court explained that suppression preserves a defendant’s rights “to the same extent as if the government’s officers had stayed within the law.” Id. at 316 (quoting State v. Vondehn, 348 Or 462, 473 (2010)). That protection extends to probation revocation because those proceedings implicate a liberty interest “sufficiently analogous to the liberty interest at stake in traditional criminal prosecutions...” Id. Because the trial court never determined whether the circumstances required Miranda warnings, the Court remanded without deciding whether a Miranda violation occurred. Reversed and remanded.


