- Court: Oregon Court of Appeals
- Area(s) of Law: Criminal Procedure
- Date Filed: 06-04-2025
- Case #: A181414
- Judge(s)/Court Below: Tookey, P.J.; Kamins, J.; DeVore, S.J.
- Full Text Opinion
Defendant appealed a conviction for second-degree rape and three counts of first-degree sexual abuse of a minor. Defendant assigned plain error to the Prosecution’s improper remarks to the jury, arguing that they denied Defendant a fair trial. Plain error is established when the comments were improper and no curative instruction to the jury is sufficient to ensure a fair trial. State v. Chitwood, 370 Or 305, (2022). The Court reasoned that the Prosecution’s assertion that Defendant was a “predator” could incite the jury’s emotions and lead them to decide the case on an improper basis. The Court further found that the Prosecution’s remarks about Defendant’s counsel were “improperly personalized” and would have distracted the jury. When holding that a jury instruction would not be curative, the Court looked at timing (the remarks were made after jury instruction), the Prosecution encouraged a conviction on an emotional basis (the predator remarks), referred to irrelevant matters outside of evidence (remarks against opposing counsel and interviewing protocols), and the decision at the trial level was a close call (lack of physical evidence and conflicting testimony). Reversed and remanded.


