Arnold v. McClanahan

Summarized by:

  • Court: Oregon Court of Appeals
  • Area(s) of Law: Civil Procedure
  • Date Filed: 06-11-2025
  • Case #: A180514
  • Judge(s)/Court Below: Lagesen, C.J.; Pagán, P.J.; O'Connor, J.
  • Full Text Opinion

Under ORCP 46, a matter is deemed to be admitted due to a failure of a timely answer or objection.

McClanahan appealed a supplemental judgment awarded to Arnold. McClanahan assigns legal error to the trial court misapplying ORCP 46 C. Arnold argued that the statute was applicable because McClanahan’s untimely response incurred further expenditures to prepare to prove the matters at trial. McClanahan argued that because the response was untimely, the court ruled those matters as admitted and therefore Arnold did not have to prove the truth of those matters at trial.  Under ORCP 46, a matter is deemed to be admitted due to a failure of a timely answer or objection. The admitted matter is then considered “conclusively established” (absent a grant for withdrawal or amendment). Furthermore, any awards granted under this statute are limited to reimbursements for expenditures accrued in proving matters that the other party failed to admit. The Court noted that in this case, the causal link was absent between Arnold’s expenditures and the requested admission. Because of the untimely response by McClanahan, the matters were deemed to be admitted, and therefore Arnold was not required to prove them at trial. Additionally, the expenditures that Arnold accrued at trial did not stem from the untimely response of McClanahan but stemmed from other matters that Arnold would have had to prove regardless. Reverse and remanded.

Advanced Search


Back to Top