- Court: Oregon Supreme Court
- Area(s) of Law: Tort Law
- Date Filed: 01-22-2026
- Case #: S070647
- Judge(s)/Court Below: Flynn, C.J. for the Court; Duncan, J.; Garrett, J.; DeHoog, J.; James, J.; Masih, J.; & Egan, J.p.t.
- Full Text Opinion
Plaintiff was injured while working for a private company contracted with the Oregon Forestry Department. The Plaintiff received worker’s compensation and then sued the state and two site managers for further damages. The lower courts ruled that the state was the sole defendant and that the Oregon Torts Claims Act protected the state and its negligent employees in situations where an individual received workers compensation. Crandall v. State of Oregon, 328 Or. App. 452, 457, 538 P.3d 212 (2023). Plaintiff appealed both decisions, arguing that immunity violated his right to a remedy under Article I, Section 10 of the Oregon Constitution.
Although statutes may modify common law remedies, the constitutionality of such statutes is determined by “the extent to which the legislature has departed from the common-law model measured against its reasons for doing so.” Horton v. OHSU, 359 Or. 168, 220, 376 P.3d 998 (2016). The Court ruled that the state was not liable here, because sovereign immunity was part of common law at the time of the OTCA's enactment. The private contractors were liable, however, because ORS 30.265(6)(a) was a substantial departure from common-law, where a third-party tortfeasor could still be sued for full damages.
“Accordingly, we remand the case to the trial court for further proceedings.”


